I have been a volunteer evaluator for Team for the Planet since 2023. I assess and score climate startup files; the decision itself is collective. Among the questions a file has to face, one comes back with metronomic regularity: what is left of the business model once the "carbon credits" line is removed from the income statement?
The question is not ideological. It is an accounting one. A startup whose margin depends on selling credits bets its survival on a price it does not set, on demand that depends on how its customers communicate, and on certification methods that keep evolving. In 2026, two of those three supports moved in Europe. What follows explains why a sound climate business model must stand without credits, and how to check it on a file.
1. What a carbon credit really brings a startup
For the seller, a carbon credit is derived revenue: it does not pay for the product, it pays for a tonne avoided or removed from the atmosphere, measured under a method, verified by a third party, then sold to a buyer who has a use for it. Every link in that chain sits outside the startup's control.
- The price forms on a market where the startup is a price taker, not a price maker. A business plan that assumes a stable or rising price over ten years rests on an assumption no founder can defend alone.
- The demand comes from buyers who, in many cases, buy credits so they can say something about their products or their company. If what they are allowed to say changes, what they buy changes.
- The method of calculation and certification decides how many tonnes are recognised. A revised method can shrink the sellable volume while nothing has changed on the ground.
None of this forbids selling credits. It only says where to put them in a model: as a complement, not as a foundation. Revenue you do not steer cannot carry fixed costs.
2. The "carbon neutral" argument has changed status
The first support that moved is demand. European Directive 2024/825 tightens the rules on environmental claims made to consumers. The French Ministry for the Ecological Transition sums it up on its page "Renforcement de l’encadrement des allégations environnementales : les effets de la directive européenne 2024/825" (updated on October 27, 2026, consulted on November 11, 2026): claims that a product has a neutral, reduced or positive environmental impact because of emissions offsetting now fall among unfair commercial practices, as a ban "parmi les pratiques commerciales déloyales en toutes circonstances" (among the commercial practices deemed unfair in all circumstances). The same page states that these provisions have applied at EU level since September 27, 2026.
The Commission page "Directive (EU) 2024/825: empowering the consumer for the green transition" (consulted on November 11, 2026) confirms the timeline: transposition by Member States by March 27, 2026, application from September 27, 2026, and a text that explicitly addresses claims about products' environmental impacts that rely on the offsetting of greenhouse gas emissions.
On the French side, the ministry's page says that transposition goes through the bill adapting French law to EU law (DDADUE), and that its provisions had not yet been definitively adopted as of its update on October 27, 2026. It also recalls the regime in place, Article L. 229-68 of the French Environmental Code: an advertiser claiming that a product is carbon neutral must publish a greenhouse gas report for the product, the approach taken to avoid, reduce and then offset, and how residual emissions are offset.
The consequence for a founder is direct. If the model sells credits to brands that used them to present a product as "neutral" to the general public, that use no longer exists in Europe. The customer may still buy credits for other reasons, but the simplest sales argument is gone. A file that has not absorbed this change describes a market that no longer exists in that form.
3. EU certification creates a framework, not a customer
The second support that moved is method, and here the movement points towards quality. The Commission page "Carbon Removals and Carbon Farming (CRCF) Regulation" (consulted on November 11, 2026) presents the regulation as the first EU-wide voluntary certification framework for permanent carbon removals, carbon farming and carbon storage in products. It mandates third-party verification and the publication of certification information in an EU-wide registry.
The methods arrive in stages. According to the Commission's "Certification methodologies" page (consulted on November 11, 2026), a delegated regulation from February 2026 sets the methods for three types of permanent removals, the Commission adopted the one covering carbon farming in July 2026, and the method for carbon storage in buildings is planned for publication by the end of 2026.
For a file, this is good news and a limit at once. A unit certified under a public method is more credible than a home-made credit. But a certification framework sets neither a price nor a purchase volume: it says what a quality tonne is, not who will pay for it. The same site also mentions a buyers club that brings together buyers and suppliers of certified units, which confirms that matching supply and demand is still work in progress. A startup that writes "EU certification guarantees our revenue" confuses the quality of a unit with the existence of a market.
4. The test: remove the credits line from the income statement
The most useful test is also the simplest. Take the projected income statement, delete the credit revenue line, and look at what is left. Three questions are enough to read the result.
- Who pays for the core service, and why? A customer paying for cooling, energy, a material or a productivity gain has a reason to buy that does not depend on their communication. That reason is what must carry the model.
- Does gross margin stay positive without credits and without subsidies? If it only does with those two lines, the product does not yet sell for what it does. That is not disqualifying at an early stage, provided the file says so and shows the path to a clean margin.
- What happens to the plan if the credit price falls sharply, or if the main buyer walks away? A serious file presents that scenario itself. A fragile file never considers it.
This test combines with a reading of technical maturity. A model that stands without credits but rests on technology still at prototype stage carries a different risk, which the TRL scale helps locate. The two readings complement each other: one says whether the solution works, the other whether someone will pay for it on its own merits.
5. When regulation works for the model
The opposite of a model hanging on credits is a model carried by a constraint the customer faces anyway. EU rules on fluorinated gases give a clear example. The Commission page "EU-Rules - Fluorinated Greenhouse Gases" (consulted on November 11, 2026) states that the 2024 regulation started to apply on March 11, 2024, that it adds prohibitions on equipment and products using these gases, and that in 2050 HFCs will be phased out in the EU.
A manufacturer that has to replace its refrigerants does not need a carbon credit to look for an alternative: the rule creates the demand. That is the case the checklist for evaluating a climate startup published on this site illustrates with Leviathan Dynamics, a startup funded by Team for the Planet (public information), which produces industrial cooling with water instead of high-warming refrigerants. Read through this criterion, the case shows the shape to look for: the customer buys cooling first, the climate impact comes with it, and regulation pushes in the same direction. That is no guarantee of success, only a model whose spine does not depend on a carbon market.
6. What a solid file shows, to a fund as to a community
- A main revenue line that pays for the product or service, not for the tonne.
- A gross margin calculated without credits and without subsidies, even provisional, with the path to improve it.
- A low credit price scenario, offered before anyone asks.
- An up-to-date reading of the law: no more sales argument built on a product made "neutral" through offsetting for European consumers.
- If credits are sold, the certification method targeted, its adoption status at the date of the file, and the identified buyer.
- The regulatory or economic constraint that pushes the customer to buy, when there is one.
These points hold whoever the reader is. A fund committee and a collective pre-selection do not read a file the same way, as the article Collective intelligence or a VC committee details, but neither is keen to fund a model whose margin depends on a price it cannot forecast.
If you are preparing a climate file or a fundraise and want to stress-test your business model before presenting it, write to me at contact@thanaelfontaine.eu or book a slot from the contact page.