I have been a volunteer evaluator for Team for the Planet since 2023. I assess and score climate startup files; the decision itself is collective: I do not choose, approve, reject or fund any startup. That position, one voice among many, gives a particular view on a question climate founders rarely ask: what changes when your file is not read by three partners of a fund, but by a community?

The short answer: the criteria barely change, the way you are read changes a lot. A venture capital committee is a small group of experts deciding on behalf of a fund. A collective intelligence process is a series of filters in which a large number of people with very different profiles each give an opinion before other bodies settle the matter. The same file is not defended the same way in each.

Who decides in a venture capital fund?

On the fund side, the frame is set by the regulator. France's Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) states that private equity funds require its approval and must be offered by management companies that are themselves approved, and that venture capital finances the creation of a company or the first developments of a young one (page consulted on October 14, 2026). The same page notes that in practice investors cannot redeem their units during the life of the fund, which can run up to 10 years or more.

Two consequences for a founder. First, the investment decision belongs to the management company: in practice, a small circle of people who know their sector well and answer for the choice to their own investors. Second, that circle reasons against a clock: a fund with a limited life must be able to sell its stakes before it closes. Your file is therefore read through an implicit question, the exit.

How Team for the Planet selects its innovations

Team for the Planet describes its process publicly on its "Become an assessor" page (published March 31, 2025, consulted October 14, 2026). Selection runs in four phases:

  1. Pre-selection by assessors. It sorts the innovations that fall within scope: responding to one of the 20 areas of focus identified against climate change, with high-impact potential on a global scale.
  2. Scientific validation by the Scientific Committee.
  3. Validation of the market potential, via growth hacking methods.
  4. Ethical validation by the Supervisory Committee and a vote by all of the shareholders.

The page justifies the first phase plainly: one or two people can get it wrong or lack objectivity, a risk that fades when many assessors with diverse profiles and knowledge give their opinions. The role is open to anyone, after a one-hour training session on the criteria; each assessor then picks the innovations they wish to score, online. Behind it, the community that has the final say is broad: the Team for the Planet home page showed 133,000 shareholders on October 14, 2026.

1. You are no longer read by specialists of your niche

A deeptech fund committee often includes someone who knows your technology. A collective pre-selection almost never does, entirely: assessors come from varied backgrounds, by design. The jargon that reassures a specialist becomes an obstacle. A file that holds up in front of a crowd explains in one sentence which climate problem it addresses, which large family of emissions it tackles, and why the solution changes the order of magnitude. If an informed but non-specialist reader cannot restate your promise after two minutes, the score shows it.

2. Individual bias matters less, consistency matters more

In front of a committee, a strong pitch can carry the room: the conviction of the partner championing the file weighs heavily. In a collective process, one reader's enthusiasm is diluted by everyone else's. What emerges is what many people perceive the same way. The files that converge are those whose claims are verifiable and consistent with each other: a stated maturity level that matches the evidence shown, a bottom-up impact estimate, a business model that does not hinge on a heroic assumption.

3. Technical maturity reads the same on both sides

Here, nothing changes. On every file, I read the maturity of the solution with the TRL scale, and a deeptech fund committee does the same reading with its own tools. Claiming "almost industrial" without test data from representative conditions costs as much in front of a community as in front of partners. The difference lies in the sanction: a committee may tell you in a meeting, a collective pre-selection will let you feel it in how the scores converge.

4. The horizon is not set by the same constraint

A venture capital fund with a limited life must be able to exit your cap table within a given period: that is a structural constraint, not a flaw. A process that starts with climate scope and global impact potential, as the one Team for the Planet describes does, puts the first question elsewhere: does your innovation answer a major emissions problem? For a founder, the consequence is practical: the same file must lead with the exit argument in front of a fund, and with the impact argument in front of a climate community, without ever sacrificing either in the text.

What a founder can prepare, whatever the jury

  • A promise a non-specialist can restate in one sentence.
  • An honest TRL level, backed by data from the latest test.
  • A bottom-up impact estimate, not an assumed share of the world market.
  • A business model that stands on its own, without relying on a favourable carbon price.
  • A page on the risks, offered before anyone asks.

These points overlap with the questions detailed in the checklist for evaluating a climate startup. They guarantee nothing: neither a committee nor a community commits to a list. But a file that ticks them can be read by three experts or by a crowd without changing its substance, only its order.

For more on the evaluator role, this site's Team for the Planet page details the process from the inside. And if you are preparing a climate file or a fundraise, write to me at contact@thanaelfontaine.eu or book a slot from the contact page.